+ HUMAN-AI SPECTRUM
These rubrics are a first attempt to objectively delineate a continuum for assessing the level of collaboration between human and artificial intelligence in the content creation process. The idea is that creators could use the VerifiedHuman® label with a number* if helpful.
VerifiedHuman® Human-AI Collaborative Spectrum
(5-point scale)
*We do not intend that any VerifiedHuman™ Creator would use a rating lower than VH3 with the label. However, we have established the limits of the spectrum from VH1 (not to be confused with the 80s music TV channel) to VH5. Anything below level VH3 would not be considered VerifiedHuman label-worthy at any rate.
Do you have some feedback?
We would love to hear from you.
A continuum for assessing the level of collaboration between human and artificial intelligence in the writing process.
WRITING RUBRIC
5 - >99% Human-Written (<1% AI-Generated):
-
The content is written entirely without any AI assistance.
-
Includes unique human perspectives, creativity, and personalized written expression.
-
There are no traces of automated processes or machine-generated syntactic patterns.
4 - Mostly Human-Written (Limited AI Assistance):
-
The content is predominantly written by humans, with minimal AI assistance.
-
AI tools for basic tasks like spell-checking, grammar correction, or simple suggestions may be used.
-
Human creativity dominates, with AI as a supplementary tool for efficiency or refinement.
3 - Balanced Human-AI Collaboration:
-
The content results from a collaborative effort between humans and AI.
-
Humans and AI share responsibilities in content creation, with a harmonious integration of ideas and generation processes.
-
AI may contribute to tasks like idea suggestions, data analysis, or content generation, while human creativity is equally significant.
2 - Mostly AI-Generated Writing (Limited Human Input):
-
AI predominantly generates the content with minimal human intervention.
-
Humans may provide initial guidelines, prompting, input, or oversight, but AI leads content creation.
-
May exhibit machine-generated patterns or styles with limited human influence.
1 - <1% Human Writing (>99% AI-Generated):
-
AI entirely and autonomously generates the content without direct human involvement beyond prompting.
-
AI is responsible for the conception, ideation, and execution of the content creation process.
-
May include machine-like patterns, precision, and efficiency, devoid of human nuances.
A continuum for assessing the level of collaboration between human and artificial intelligence in the creation of visual art. It's important to note that visual arts encompass a wide range of mediums, including painting, drawing, photography, sculpture, architecture, dance, and other visible art forms.
VISUAL ARTS RUBRIC
5 - >99% Human-Created (<1% AI-Generated):
-
The product is created by humans without any AI assistance.
-
Includes unique human perspective, creativity, and personalized artistic expression.
-
There are no traces of automated processes or machine-generated visual patterns.
4 - Mostly Human-Created (Limited AI Assistance):
-
The product is predominantly created by humans, with minimal AI assistance.
-
AI tools may be used for technical enhancements, color correction, or other essential tasks.
-
Human artistic expression dominates, with AI as a supplementary efficiency or technical refinement tool.
3 - Balanced Human-AI Collaboration:
-
The product results from a collaborative effort between humans and AI.
-
Humans contribute significantly to the artistic vision, creativity, and decision-making in the visual creation process.
-
AI is actively involved in tasks such as generating visual elements, suggesting artistic styles, or assisting in technical execution.
2 - Mostly AI-Generated (Limited Human Input):
-
AI predominantly generates the product with minimal human intervention.
-
Humans may provide initial guidelines, input, or oversight, but the AI takes the lead in creating the visual content.
-
It may exhibit machine-generated styles or patterns with limited human artistic influence.
1 - <1% Human (>99% AI-Generated):
-
AI entirely and autonomously generates visual art without direct human involvement beyond prompting.
-
AI is responsible for the conception, design, and execution of the visual creation process.
-
It may include machine-generated patterns, precision, and efficiency, devoid of human artistic nuances.
A continuum for assessing the level of collaboration between human and artificial intelligence in the process of creating music.
MUSIC RUBRIC
5 - >99% Human-Created (<1% AI-Generated):
-
The music is composed entirely without any AI assistance.
-
Includes unique human perspectives, creativity, and personalized musical expression.
-
There are no traces of automated processes or machine-generated musical patterns.
4 - Mostly Human-Created (Limited AI Assistance):
-
The music is predominantly composed by humans, with minimal AI assistance.
-
AI tools may be used for technical aspects like music notation, sound mixing, pitch, tuning, or other essential tasks.
-
Human creativity dominates, with AI as a supplementary tool for efficiency or refinement.
3 - Balanced Human-AI Collaboration:
-
The music results from a collaborative effort between humans and AI.
-
Humans and AI share responsibilities in music creation, with a harmonious integration of ideas and generation processes.
-
AI may contribute to tasks like melody suggestions, rhythm patterns, or instrument selection, while human creativity plays an equally significant role.
2 - Mostly AI-Generated (Limited Human Input):
-
AI predominantly generates the music with minimal human intervention.
-
Humans may provide initial guidelines, thematic input, or oversight, but AI takes the lead in composing the music.
-
It may exhibit machine-generated musical patterns or styles with limited human influence.
1 - <1% Human (>99% AI-Generated):
-
AI entirely and autonomously generates the music without direct human involvement beyond prompting.
-
AI is responsible for the conception, composition, and execution of the entire music creation process.
-
It may include machine-like patterns, precision, and efficiency, devoid of human nuances.
A continuum for assessing the level of collaboration between human and artificial intelligence in the production of spoken audio content.
5 - >99% Human-Created (<1% AI-Generated):
-
The vocal content is produced entirely without any AI assistance.
-
Includes unique vocal nuances, emotional depth, and personalized vocalized expression.
-
There are no traces of automated processes or machine-generated voice patterns.
4 - Mostly Human-Created (Limited AI Assistance):
-
The vocal content is predominantly produced by humans, with minimal AI assistance.
-
AI tools may be used for technical enhancements, noise reduction, or other essential tasks.
-
Human vocal expression dominates, with AI as a supplementary efficiency or technical refinement tool.
3 - Balanced Human-AI Collaboration:
-
The vocal content results from a collaborative effort between humans and AI.
-
Humans contribute significantly to emotional expression, artistic interpretation, and decision-making in the voiceover process.
-
AI is actively involved in speech generation, voice modulation, or technical enhancements.
2 - Mostly AI-Generated (Limited Human Input):
-
AI predominantly generates the vocal content with minimal human intervention.
Humans may provide initial guidelines, input, or oversight, but the AI takes the lead in producing the voiceover.
-
It may exhibit machine-generated patterns with limited human vocal influence.
1 - <1% Human (>99% AI-Generated):
-
AI entirely and autonomously generates the vocal content without direct human involvement beyond prompting.
-
AI creates the entire voiceover, including intonation, emotion, and speech patterns.
-
It may include machine-generated voice patterns, precision, and efficiency, devoid of human vocal nuances.
VOICE ACTING RUBRIC
